Before You Judge: Walking in Noetic Discernment With God

My inside screams at me lately. There are so many people out there who are proclaiming what is right and what is wrong. They are so busy telling anyone who will read or listen to them that the way others believe needs adjustment or these people are just plain wrong.

My suggestion is this:

Matthew 7:3-5And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?  Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother’s eye.

I have no time to point out others’ shortcomings when I am trying to get past my own. There is too much time to devote to developing a solid relationship with God. If I’m wrong about anything, I ask God to show me where I need to adjust. I know I’m not perfect (or I should say “fully mature”). I’m still growing in Him. For the most part, I consider my morning conversations with God to be aimed at that very endeavor.

I’ve developed enough maturity to be more careful about keeping my relationship with God secure. I keep my “knower” in check to not go beyond using it to condemn another member of the Body of Christ. My “knower” is what comes from my knowledge of the Word of God and ability to hear the Holy Spirit quickening me to be aware of truth or error.

A Greek word best describes what I’m saying. Noetic derives from the Greek adjective noētikos, meaning “intellectual,” from the verb noein (“to think”) and ultimately from the noun nous, meaning “mind.” Noetic is related to noesis, a rare noun that turns up in the field of philosophy and refers to the action of perceiving or thinking.

I consider this a step toward discernment. In general, discernment is accurately evaluating ourselves, people, and situations. We discern things correctly by clearly perceiving what is true, right, and essential. “To examine, prove, or test; scrutinize.” I don’t consider it judgment. In discernment, we weigh the knowledge of a thing, but we do not condemn it. It is a device of our makeup to protect us or to allow us to open up to what we encounter.

With that said, I don’t want to bring about condemnation of another soul who likely has a calling in their life. I just need to know whether they are using that calling correctly.

Psalm 105:14-15He suffered no man to do them wrong: yea, he reproved kings for their sakes, saying, Touch not my anointed, and do my prophets no harm.

If anyone has a problem with a called man or woman of God, it is best to go directly to them and speak with them. I’m pointing towards a protocol for handling an errant minister of God. If it isn’t done right, we find ourselves no better than the one we deem to call out.

The protocol for addressing an errant member of the ministry typically involves several steps, starting with private, one-on-one conversations to address the issue directly. If the member remains unrepentant, the process may escalate to involving other church leaders and could ultimately lead to formal church discipline, including removal from membership.

With that said, we have no right to get on a soapbox and shout out the perceived wrongdoings of another. You will put yourself in jeopardy of discipline in the spiritual realm. I’m not willing to go so far as to have this type of encounter. That discipline comes directly from God.

Unknown's avatar

About JimR, Chaplain

I'm a 75-year-old guy, in October 2025, who worked in Naval Hospital Camp Lejeune for 28 years and now retired as of 31 Dec 16. I've worked in medical records, the Health Benefits Department, Billing, and the IT department and retired as the Personnel Security Manager for the hospital. I'm a musician and Corvette enthusiast. Yes, I have had two. I traded my second Corvette for a Harley Davidson Fat Boy in mid-summer 2019. Then in 2024, I traded to an HD FreeWheeler FLRT. I've already ridden the new one a thousand miles in 6 weeks. I'm also searching for a fresh new outlook on life with new spiritual insight among other things. I was ordained a minister in 20190202. I've become certified with the American Chaplaincy Association through Aidan University in June '21. Presently, I am a volunteer Chaplain with our county Sheriff's Office. I've found that with the unconditional love of my companion, Libby Rowe life is complete through God. She's a beautiful, vibrant, giving woman who gives her all in everything she puts her mind to do. She and I married on 24 July 2015. She was ordained in February 2022. She has a blog too called Under a Carolina Moon. Give it a visit.
This entry was posted in Biblical teaching, Christian, Common Sense, Failure Not An Option, Growing up, Maturity, Salvation, Sobering Thoughts, Spiritual Growth and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.